CallRail Vs WhatConverts: Which One Should You Use?
We've deployed both platforms across dozens of client accounts. Both are solid. But after two years of side-by-side use, one of them consistently wins — and it's not always for the reasons you'd expect.
If you're running paid ads for a service business, you need call tracking. That's not debatable. Without it, you're blind to 40–70% of your conversions. The question is which platform to use. CallRail and WhatConverts are the two most common answers, and we've used both extensively. Here's our honest comparison.
Feature-By-Feature Comparison
| Feature | CallRail | WhatConverts |
|---|---|---|
| Dynamic Number Insertion | ✓ Excellent | ✓ Good |
| Call Recording & Transcription | ✓ AI-powered | ✓ Available |
| Form Tracking | ✓ Built-in | ✓ Core feature |
| Chat Tracking | ✓ Available | ✓ Available |
| Multi-Touch Attribution | ✓ Strong | ✓ Good |
| Google Ads Integration | ✓ Native | ✓ Available |
| GA4 Integration | ✓ Seamless | ◐ Requires setup |
| Conversation Intelligence / AI | ✓ Advanced | ✗ Not available |
| Lead Qualification Scoring | ✓ AI-based | ✓ Manual rules |
| White-Label Reporting | ◐ Limited | ✓ Strong |
| Ease of Setup | ✓ Very easy | ✓ Easy |
| Starting Price | $45/mo | $30/mo |
Our Scoring
Where CallRail Wins
Conversation intelligence is the differentiator. CallRail's AI features transcribe calls, identify keywords, and automatically tag leads as qualified or unqualified. For businesses getting 50+ calls per month, this saves hours of manual review and gives you data you can actually act on. WhatConverts simply doesn't have an equivalent feature.
The Google Ads integration is also tighter. CallRail pushes conversion data back into Google Ads natively, which means your smart bidding algorithms get better signal. This directly impacts your cost per acquisition.
Setup is also faster. We can have CallRail fully deployed on a client site — dynamic number insertion, form tracking, GA4 integration — in under 30 minutes.
Where WhatConverts Wins
Reporting and white-labeling. If you're an agency that needs to generate branded client reports with lead data, WhatConverts has stronger out-of-the-box reporting templates. The lead management interface is also good for manual lead qualification workflows where you want human review of every lead.
WhatConverts is also slightly cheaper at the entry level ($30/mo vs $45/mo), though the feature gap widens significantly at higher tiers.
When to Pick Each
- Pick CallRail if: You run Google Ads, need conversation intelligence, want tight GA4 integration, or get more than 30 calls per month. It's the better tool for CRO-focused businesses that want to optimize based on call data.
- Pick WhatConverts if: You're a marketing agency focused on lead reporting and white-label client dashboards, or if you need a budget option for basic call and form tracking.
Our Recommendation: CallRail
For the vast majority of service businesses and performance-focused agencies, CallRail is the stronger choice. The conversation intelligence features, Google Ads integration depth, and ease of setup make it our default recommendation. We use it across 90%+ of our client accounts.
The AI transcription and lead scoring alone justify the price difference — they turn call data from a black box into an optimization lever.
Try CallRail →Disclosure: The CallRail link above is a partner link. We recommend CallRail because we use it and it works — the partnership exists because of that, not the other way around.
Need help setting up call tracking?
We'll get CallRail deployed on your site with full attribution in under an hour.
Get Your Free CRO Analysis →